Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
One of the most consequential decisions a retiree can face is whether to take a pension as a lump sum or as monthly payments over a lifetime.
And one of the things that drives me a little crazy as a financial planner is how often people make this decision based on what their neighbor did.
“My brother-in-law took the lump sum and he’s thrilled.”
“My neighbor took the monthly payments and swears by it.”
The pension lump sum vs. monthly payments decision is one of the most personal financial decisions you’ll ever make.
Let me walk you through five filters that will help you approach this decision the right way.
First: A Story
I recently met with a woman who had made this exact decision before we started working together. She told me about a friend who had strongly recommended she take the lump sum instead of the monthly payments.
Her friend was very happy with his decision. So she took his advice and took the lump sum too.
She made the right decision.
But not because her friend was right. She made the right decision because HER specific situation supported it:
- Both she and her spouse were healthy with family longevity on their side
- They had strong guaranteed income from another pension and two Social Security benefits
- Their guaranteed income covered ALL essential expenses AND the vast majority of discretionary expenses
- She valued the ability to leave a legacy to her daughters
- Her risk tolerance was higher because she wasn’t relying on this money for basic needs
The lump sum was right for her. But she got there through the wrong process, by trusting her friend’s recommendation rather than analyzing her own situation.
She could have just as easily taken the same advice and made the wrong decision if her situation had been different.
Had I been analyzing her situation, I would’ve recommended she take the following into consideration:
Filter #1: Credit Risk of the Underlying Pension
The first question worth asking is whether the pension will actually be there for you over the next 20-30 years.
This concern is legitimate but often overblown, and it depends significantly on whether your pension is private or public.
Private Pensions:
Private company pensions ARE subject to credit risk. If the company goes under, the pension can be affected.
Take FirstEnergy, the Midwest energy company. In 2020, FirstEnergy faced serious challenges – its corporate bonds were downgraded to junk status, and negative press surrounded the company. For retirees relying on that pension for the next 20-30 years, the anxiety was real.
But the pension itself was never downgraded. Pension assets are typically held in a separate trust from the company’s operating assets.
FirstEnergy had also transferred much of its pension risk to insurance companies, which are generally better suited to handle actuarial risk than corporate balance sheets.
Today, FirstEnergy is back to investment-grade credit, and its pension continues to pay out as promised.
But other companies HAVE failed catastrophically. Bethlehem Steel in Pennsylvania went belly-up around 2002, and its pension system had to be liquidated.
Private pensions also have a backup.
The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) backs private pensions. If your company’s pension fails, the PBGC steps in.
There ARE limits on how much they’ll pay. For a joint and survivor lifetime benefit, the maximum annual payout from PBGC is currently just over $7,000 per month (this figure adjusts annually – check for current limits).
If your pension benefit is above the cap, you could take a haircut. But for most retirees with modest pension benefits, the PBGC will cover them fully.
Public Pensions:
Public sector pensions are NOT covered by the PBGC.
Pennsylvania teachers, for example, are covered by PSERS (Pennsylvania State Employees’ Retirement System). If PSERS were to fail, the backing would come from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, not the PBGC.
Federal government pensions are backed by the federal government. Local government pensions are backed by the relevant municipality.
What to do:
Check the credit rating of your pension’s sponsor. For public pensions, understand the funding status of the plan. For private pensions, know whether you’re within PBGC coverage limits.
For most retirees, credit risk shouldn’t be the deciding factor – but it deserves to be a checked box in your analysis.
Filter #2: Life Expectancy (Yours and Your Spouse’s)
Pensions with monthly payments pay for as long as you live (and, if you elect a survivor option, as long as your spouse lives).
Lump sums, once distributed, are yours to manage, but they can also run out.
The math on this filter depends heavily on how long you actually live.
If you have concerns about your health or family longevity:
If you have serious health concerns, family history of shorter lifespans, or a spouse whose health is uncertain, the monthly payment stream has less value to you. A monthly payment for 5-10 years is dramatically different from a monthly payment for 30 years.
In this scenario, a lump sum might make more sense, especially if you want to leave something to heirs.
If you and your spouse are healthy with a long runway ahead:
If you’re both 65, both in good health, and family history suggests you might live to 90+, the monthly payment stream becomes very valuable.
Consider: if you take a $500,000 lump sum and manage it yourself over 30 years, you’ll need investment discipline, favorable markets, and careful spending to make it last. The monthly payment, meanwhile, will keep coming for as long as either of you is alive.
The reality:
Life expectancy is impossible to predict with certainty. But the general rule is: if both spouses are healthy and at least age 65, plan for at least ONE of you to have a long life expectancy.
The pension’s guaranteed lifetime income can be a powerful hedge against longevity risk.
Filter #3: Your Other Sources of Income
This might be the most important filter of all.
If you have strong other income:
- Robust Social Security for both spouses
- Another pension
- Substantial retirement account balances
- Rental income or other passive streams
…then the pension monthly payment may be redundant income. You already have your essential expenses covered. In this case, a lump sum that can be invested for growth, legacy, or flexibility may serve you better.
The woman I mentioned earlier fit this profile perfectly. Her existing income was more than enough. Taking the lump sum lets her invest for growth without threatening her lifestyle.
If you have modest other income:
If Social Security is your only other guaranteed income and it doesn’t cover much beyond basic expenses, the pension monthly payment becomes essential income.
In this case, giving up monthly guaranteed income for a lump sum you have to manage is much riskier. Every month you’re not receiving that payment is a month you have to fund from an unpredictable portfolio.
A real-world example:
The client I mentioned took a $170,000 lump sum. She and her husband had another pension, plus two Social Security benefits that more than covered their needs.
She rolled the lump sum into an IRA, invested it, and over the next 9-10 years – through market ups and downs – she more than doubled her money. She’s only taken required minimum distributions since then.
Her decision worked. But it worked BECAUSE she had other income. Had she needed to draw on that lump sum for basic living expenses, especially during market downturns, she might have made a decision she’d regret.
Filter #4: What Will You Actually DO With the Lump Sum?
This is the filter people overlook the most.
If you take the lump sum, what’s the plan?
If you’ll invest it conservatively:
You might end up defeating the purpose. If you take a lump sum and put it in a money market or CDs at 4%, you may actually get LESS income than the pension would have provided. You’ve traded guaranteed income for uncertain income and potentially received LESS of it.
Unless you have specific reasons for keeping it conservative (like planning to gift it soon, or having very low risk tolerance), this often isn’t the best use of the lump sum.
If you’ll invest it for long-term growth:
Then you’re accepting market risk in exchange for potential long-term returns. Over 20-30 years, a diversified portfolio may substantially outperform the pension’s implied return – but you’ll also experience volatility along the way.
If you can handle that emotionally AND financially (meaning you don’t need to draw on it during downturns), the lump sum can work well.
If you have specific legacy goals:
Some retirees take the lump sum specifically to leave something to heirs. A monthly pension typically ends when you (or you and your spouse) die. A lump sum invested wisely can pass to the next generation.
The critical question:
Your investment strategy for the lump sum should MATCH your goals and time horizon. Taking a lump sum and then not knowing what to do with it is often worse than just taking the monthly payments.
Filter #5: Inflation Protection (COLA)
A factor most retirees underweight: what will your pension actually BUY in 20 or 30 years?
Only about 1 in 10 private pensions have a Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA).
That means for most private pension recipients, the monthly payment you receive on day one is the same monthly payment you’ll receive on the day you die – even if that’s 30 years later.
Let’s do the math. At 3% inflation:
- $4,000/month today buys about $2,214/month in purchasing power in 20 years
- That same $4,000/month buys about $1,647/month in 30 years
Your pension effectively loses purchasing power every single year without a COLA.
Public pensions vary:
Many public sector pensions do have COLA adjustments, though not all. If your public pension has a COLA, that dramatically improves the value of the monthly payment option.
“But Social Security has COLA…”
Yes, and I’d encourage you to ask an 80-year-old retiree what they think of the Social Security COLA adjustment. I’ve yet to meet one whose eyes beamed with excitement when you bring it up.
Medicare premium increases can eat into the Social Security COLA. So while you might get a 3% raise, if your Medicare premium goes up 6%, your take-home increase is much smaller than you’d think.
The COLA piece matters. It should be a serious part of your analysis.
Putting It All Together
Once you’ve worked through all five filters:
- Credit risk of the pension sponsor
- Life expectancy for you and your spouse
- Other guaranteed income and whether the pension is essential or supplemental
- What you’ll actually do with a lump sum
- Inflation protection through COLA or lack thereof
You may find all five filters point in the same direction. That’s your answer.
More often, you’ll find some point toward lump sum and others toward monthly payments. That’s normal – and that’s when the real analysis begins.
When filters conflict:
If it’s split 4-1 or 3-2, look at which filters carry the most weight for YOUR specific situation. For someone in poor health with a strong other income, life expectancy dominates. For someone with modest other income and long life expectancy, the guaranteed monthly income dominates.
When it truly is close:
Sometimes you’ll do the analysis and find it’s genuinely a close call. Both options are legitimate. This isn’t unusual with a decision this important.
In that case, ask yourself: which option lets you sleep at night?
Take the one that gives you the most peace of mind.
That’s a legitimate tiebreaker – but ONLY after you’ve done the actual analysis. Skipping the analysis and defaulting to “whatever feels right” leads to the mistakes we’ve been discussing.
The Action Steps
If you’re facing this decision (or will be), here’s what to do:
1. Get the numbers from your plan.
Request all the options: lump sum, single life annuity, joint and survivor annuities at various percentages (50%, 75%, 100%). You can’t compare what you don’t know.
2. Check credit rating and COLA.
Understand the credit strength of the pension sponsor. Determine whether there’s a COLA on the monthly payment option. These are yes/no facts you can look up.
3. Assess your life expectancy honestly.
Consider your health, your spouse’s health, and family history. Don’t be overly optimistic OR pessimistic.
4. Do a thorough inventory of your other income.
List every source of guaranteed income (Social Security, other pensions, annuities). Compare it to your essential and discretionary expenses. Is the pension monthly payment essential income or supplemental?
5. Decide what you’d do with a lump sum.
If your answer is “I don’t know,” that’s a sign the monthly payments might be safer. If you have a specific investment strategy and time horizon, evaluate whether that strategy is likely to outperform the pension’s guaranteed income.
6. Walk through the five filters and see how they align.
Weight them for your specific situation. Where do they point?
7. If it’s still close, sleep on it – literally.
The peace-of-mind tiebreaker is legitimate. But only AFTER the analysis.
The Warning
Please don’t take one thing away from this article and ignore the rest: do not make this decision based on what your neighbor did.
Your neighbor’s analysis was for them. They may have great insight into how they made THEIR decision. They can’t make yours for you.
The pension lump sum vs. monthly payments decision is:
- Deeply personal
- Depends on YOUR specific circumstances
- Has consequences that last decades
- Can’t easily be reversed
It deserves an actual, structured analysis.
If you have a pension decision coming up and the decision feels overwhelming or you are not sure what path to take, working with a fiduciary financial planner can help you better evaluate your options and feel confident about your decision. These types of significant financial decisions can play a compounding factor over the course of several decades, so you want to make sure you are confident in your plan.
Make the decision that’s right for YOUR life. Not your neighbor’s.
If you’re facing a pension decision and want help working through the five filters for your specific situation, we can help. At Hyperion Financial, we’ve helped clients navigate this exact decision many times. We don’t have a bias toward one answer – we help you find the right answer for your circumstances. Click here to schedule a conversation.